Donetsk Memorial • Kharkiv Human Rights Group
Ukr

Detention in wartime: overcrowding of remand centres and humanitarian challenges

  Andriy Didenko 
This article was translated using artificial intelligence. Please note that the translation may not be entirely accurate.View the original article
As of 1 August 2026, 14 pre-trial detention centres (remand prisons) and 10 penal institutions functioning as pre-trial facilities were operating in Ukraine. At the same time, four remand prisons and one penal institution lacked any protective shelters whatsoever. However, even the availability of a shelter does not guarantee that detainees will be able to access it. In this study, we examine the causes of overcrowding in remand facilities, the associated risks during wartime, and put forward recommendations for revising the practice of remanding individuals in custody as a preventive measure.

The study addresses the problems of the excessive use of remand in custody, the overcrowding of pre-trial detention centres (remand prisons), and the protection of detainees during war. It is grounded in an analysis of judicial practice, official data, judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), and the findings of monitoring visits carried out by the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group (KHPG).

Article 183 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine defines detention in custody as an exceptional preventive measure. However, the failure to make sufficient use of alternative measures leads to overcrowding in remand facilities, where individuals covered by the presumption of innocence are held. The systemic character of these issues is confirmed by the judgments of the ECtHR in the cases of ‘Ignatov v. Ukraine’ and ‘Sukachov v. Ukraine’.

The full-scale war has made these problems even more perilous. The Russian strike on Bilenke Correctional Colony No. 99 on the night of 28–29 July 2025, which killed and wounded convicts, highlighted the mortal risks faced by individuals in places of detention. Detainees locked in cells are incapable of saving themselves. This institutional helplessness entails the individual’s complete dependence on the state for their own safety.

It is therefore essential to assess not merely the occupancy rate of a remand facility, but also the actual protective capacity of the institution — its ability to safeguard people in a timely manner against wartime threats. The mere existence of a shelter does not imply that detainees are able to make use of it.

Article 2 of the Convention places positive obligations on the state to protect life. Decisions to remand in custody are not made inside pre-trial detention centres, yet it is precisely there that individuals bear their consequences — in sub-standard conditions, overcrowded cells, and under the constant threat of shelling and missile strikes.

The study raises two key questions:

  • is remanding individuals in custody always justified, and does the practice of applying this measure accord with the legislature’s intent regarding its purpose and spirit;
  • is the state capable of ensuring proper and safe conditions of detention, particularly under the conditions of war.

Relieving the pressure on remand facilities does not begin within the facilities themselves, but with a well-reasoned judicial decision. Nevertheless, the state’s responsibility does not end in the courtroom — it persists each and every day that a person remains deprived of their liberty.

The full text of the study is available via the link: Overcrowding of pre-trial detention facilities. Detention in wartime.pdf

share the information