Donetsk Memorial • Kharkiv Human Rights Group
Ukr

The right to complain behind bars: why do some penal colonies have hundreds of petitions and others none at all?

  Andriy Didenko  khpg.org
This article was translated using artificial intelligence. Please note that the translation may not be entirely accurate.View the original article
A new study by the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group covering 2025–2026 has revealed substantial discrepancies across various penal colonies in the way convicts exercise their right of petition to the Ombudsman, the prosecutor’s office, and human rights organisations. In some institutions, not a single appeal has been recorded over an extended period. Does this mean convicts have no grievances, or are they simply unable or afraid to complain?

Silence behind bars: what the research shows

The right of petition is one of the most vital mechanisms for safeguarding individuals in places of detention. It is through complaints that convicts can report substandard conditions of detention, violence, lack of medical care, violations of labour rights, and other abuses.

For several years, the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group has been examining how effectively this mechanism actually functions in Ukrainian penitentiary institutions.

The first study, published in 2023, found that in 18 out of 76 institutions not a single petition had been recorded to the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights. Moreover, in 12 institutions there were likewise no appeals to the prosecutor’s office or to human rights organisations.

The subsequent study for 2023–2024 showed that the problem remained acute: five colonies once again recorded not a single petition to the Ombudsman.

We have now analysed new official records obtained in response to freedom of information requests concerning the dispatch of correspondence for 2025–2026.

What do the figures show?

The summary table provides data for 65 penitentiary institutions.

For 2025, data on petitions to the Ombudsman are available for 55 institutions. In total, they recorded 980 petitions to the Commissioner and 4,528 to the prosecutor’s office. At the same time, ten institutions did not record a single petition to the Ombudsman, and 24 recorded none to human rights organisations.

According to the data provided for 2026, 65 institutions reported 1,052 petitions to the Ombudsman and 3,297 to the prosecutor’s office. Twelve institutions recorded not a single petition to the Commissioner, and 37 recorded none to human rights organisations.

Mashivka Correctional Colony No. 9, Pivdennoukrainsk CC No. 83, Snihurivka CC No. 5, Kachanivka CC No. 54, and Zhytomyr CC No. 4 warrant particular attention, as zero figures for petitions to the Ombudsman recurred across both periods under review.

At the same time, the statistics in other institutions are entirely different. For instance, in Kyiv SIZO (remand prison), 318 petitions to the Ombudsman and 1,114 to the prosecutor’s office were recorded for 2025. In Kharkiv SIZO, the numbers were 83 and 686 respectively.

Naturally, the volume of petitions depends on the inmate population of an institution, their legal awareness, the availability of legal aid, and other factors. In addition, the 2026 data cover an incomplete calendar year, making a direct comparison with the full year of 2025 inappropriate.

Nevertheless, such substantial discrepancies demand an explanation. Why do convicts in some institutions regularly seek protection, while in others statistical silence has reigned for years?

Can convicts complain without fear?

During monitoring visits to penitentiary institutions, human rights defenders repeatedly encounter problems of convicts being insufficiently informed about protection mechanisms, difficulties in accessing legal aid, and fears of adverse consequences after lodging complaints.

A zero return of petitions does not in itself prove interference with correspondence. However, the recurrence of such figures over several years constitutes grounds for an in-depth investigation.

Particularly revealing are the statistics on complaints concerning the actions or omissions of institutional administrations. For 2025, the relevant column of the table lists only 21 such complaints, and for 2026, a mere 39.

A natural question arises: do convicts really complain about the administration so seldom?

It cannot be ruled out that the reason also lies in the specificities of statistical record-keeping, given that the contents of confidential correspondence should not be accessible to the administration.

Article 113 of the Criminal Executive Code of Ukraine, Rules 56–57 of the Mandela Rules, and Rule 70 of the European Prison Rules provide guarantees for exercising the right of petition, the confidentiality of specified categories of correspondence, and protection against adverse consequences for lodging complaints.

These guarantees must function not merely as a formality, but in practice.

‘Prison Portal’: information that helps defend rights

One reason for the low volume of petitions may be that convicts and their relatives are insufficiently informed about legal remedies.

It is for this reason that the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group recommends using the information resource ‘Prison Portal’, which brings together useful materials for convicts, remand prisoners, their relatives, and anyone involved in the protection of human rights in places of detention.

The portal provides template applications, complaints, and other documents, answers to common legal queries, materials on conditions of detention, medical care, and convict labour, as well as reports from monitoring visits to penitentiary institutions.

These materials help individuals better understand their rights, draft the necessary petition, and identify potential avenues of legal protection.

It is vital that information regarding such resources be accessible directly within penitentiary institutions, and that convicts have a genuine opportunity to use the means of communication provided for by law.

The right to complain must not remain a formality

The findings of three consecutive studies by the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group underscore the need for a systemic review of the accessibility of human rights protection mechanisms in Ukrainian penitentiary institutions.

Particular scrutiny should be directed towards colonies where not a single petition to the Ombudsman or human rights organisations has been registered over a period of several years.

During monitoring visits, it is necessary to inspect not only outgoing correspondence logs, but also the actual capacity of convicts to petition independent bodies in confidence, receive replies, and remain free from victimisation for lodging complaints.

A large volume of petitions does not necessarily indicate a poor situation in an institution. And conversely, an absence of complaints by no means signifies an absence of violations.

After all, the right of petition is meaningful only when an individual can exercise it without fear, obstruction, or the risk of punishment.

Behind prison walls, a person may lose their liberty, but they must not lose their voice. And the State is duty-bound to do everything possible to ensure that this voice is heard.

share the information